Gerhard Marx Wins Case Against BMW and Ireland Davenport

Wednesday, October 08, 2008

From the M&G:

Last week BMW and its advertising agency, Ireland Davenport, offered Marx an out-of-court settlement and apology for copyright infringement.

In 2005 Marx held a solo exhibition at the Warren Siebrits gallery in Johannesburg, in which he showcased a technique he had developed of creating line illustrations from roads on map fragments.

Ireland Davenport used the idea in a 2006 newspaper campaign advertising the BMW Z4. According to sources close to the artist he claimed R1,5-million in damages.

On September 25 some of South Africa's top artists, including William Kentridge and Penny Siopis, donated their works to an auction to raise funds for Marx's legal fees. The auction, held at Newtown's Bag Factory art studios, raised about R450 000.

Legal fees were estimated to be R300 000, the balance will be used to set up a David and Goliath Fund, which will help artists in future plagiarism claims.

In a statement this week attorney Owen Dean said Marx, Ireland Davenport and BMW SA had "amicably" settled the case.

The agency said it had no intention of associating its campaign with Marx's work, adding that it "fully supports the arts and regrets if any impression to the contrary was given".

The apology contradicts a report in The Star earlier this week in which BMW spokesperson Benedict Maaga said the company "contests the assertion that it has infringed the rights of the artist Gerhard Marx or plagiarised his work".

Pretoria-based Owen, who represented the family of deceased composer Solomon Linda in a royalties claim against Disney Enterprises over The Lion Sleeps Tonight, said that copyright infringement is on the increase in South Africa.

"There is a cavalier attitude, one of the problems is that it is now so easy to reproduce works -- like downloading them from the internet." Dean said.

The David and Goliath fund, he said, could play an important role because the Copyright Act is expensive to enforce.

"It is a pity that the Act is not really achieving its purpose," he said.


Congratulations, Gerhard. I'm sure it's been a tough trip.

1 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

the motherfucker won! woo hoo!

1:21 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

Calendar lists the latest South African contemporary art exhibitions and events



Project is an open, free online project space for contemporary artists. Every three months ArtHeat awards a grant of up to R1500 to an artist or collective to occupy the project space. The space is also free year round for self-funded projects. Artists' get use of a page for up to three months.

Submit a proposal for Project. Email a proposal and budget to

Next Deadline: 1st November 2008

Currently in Project

The CitySkin collective are currently occupying the project space. View their project here

DataBase is a community website of contemporary Southern African art that you can edit.

The aim of DataBase is to create a central resource on contemporary Southern African art, built in a decentralised way. The idea is to draw from our collective experience to produce a knowledge base that is free of any hierarchy. The concept of sharing knowledge, where the production of knowledge is a process of giving as well as taking, is important in the current field of contemporary art discourse, where an absence of production is producing an absence of consumption.

DataBase is about sharing knowledge about topics, people, and work in the field of contemporary art. The focus is on Southern Africa, but any relevant pages are welcome.
Go to DataBase

What's New on DataBase

What's Changed on DataBase

Technorati Profile